guest post // 4 Best Practices for Marketing Your Nonprofit Thrift Store
By Kyle Payton, ThriftCart
Thrift stores provide nonprofits with additional funding that doesn’t increase fundraising or donor fatigue, making them extremely valuable for charitable missions. However, running a thrift store requires a slightly different skillset than you would usually employ at a nonprofit, which can lead to discouraging results.
In particular, thrift store marketing has nuances you might not be familiar with, and success in this competitive market depends on your ability to connect with potential shoppers and supporters. In this guide, we’ll discuss a few top tips for how you can reach more potential shoppers and boost your thrift store’s revenue.
1. Optimize Your Website and Digital Storefront
Your website is often the first point of contact for both shoppers and donors. To avoid frustrating potential customers, create a clear landing page on your nonprofit’s website for your thrift store and make it easy for users to find. For example, add the page to your navigation header so visitors can easily navigate to it.
Your thrift store’s landing page should clearly outline:
The store’s address
Store hours
Donation hours
How to donate
Accepted items
Any other specific rules related to your thrift store, such as how to handle large donations
Once you’ve built it out, take the time to optimize your page and your website as a whole to improve the user experience. You might:
Feature a prominent call to action (CTA) to schedule donation pickups or view daily specials.
Use high-quality imagery of your current inventory to entice shoppers to visit and give your site a professional look.
Ensure your site is accessible, mobile-friendly, and loads quickly to prevent high bounce rates.
Embed a newsletter sign-up form specifically for inventory alerts or "First Look" weekly drops to build a direct marketing channel.
Nonprofits that operate an e-commerce thrift store should also keep an eye out for ways to streamline their digital storefront. You might implement a "Buy Online, Pickup In-Store" (BOPIS) model, which serves as a powerful marketing hook to guarantee shoppers do not miss out on one-of-a-kind finds while simultaneously driving physical foot traffic.
Additionally, ThriftCart recommends investing in a robust thrift store POS system with e-commerce capabilities. Use these solutions to create an online store that syncs inventory with your physical location, keeping your inventory management accurate and preventing overselling.
2. Use Local SEO and Your Google Business Profile
Most thrift shoppers start their journey with a search for "thrift store near me." If your store does not appear in the top results, you may be losing significant foot traffic. Fortunately, local search engine optimization (SEO) ensures your store is visible online when customers are looking to shop or donate.
Here are a few easy ways to leverage local SEO:
Make sure that your thrift store’s name, address, and phone number are consistent across all online directories.
Use local keywords like "vintage clothing [City Name]" or "charity shop" in your business description.
Update your Google Business Profile regularly with photos of seasonal displays and standout new arrivals.
Promptly respond to all reviews to show Google that your business is active and reliable.
Create a "Google Review" QR code and display it at the checkout counter to increase the volume of positive feedback.
High visibility in local search results acts as a digital billboard. When your store is featured at the top of search engine results pages and in their maps, it signals to the community that you’re a trusted resale leader in the region, which attracts more customers and even higher-quality donations.
3. Leverage Social Proof and Storytelling
Thrift shoppers all have different motivations. Many are deal hunters looking for affordable items to purchase. Others want to purchase one-of-a-kind or vintage items. And some just want to patronize your store to support your mission. Social proof and storytelling help you connect with all of these shoppers and show them the impact of their purchases.
Use your marketing channels to highlight how thrift store proceeds fund your nonprofit’s core programs and how those programs benefit the local community. Connecting a purchase at your thrift store to a social outcome transforms how people see your store — they’re not just buying an item, they’re also making a difference.
Get creative with social proof and storytelling to market your thrift store. For example, you can:
Use in-store signage to remind shoppers they are "shopping for a cause" and contributing to your nonprofit’s mission.
Post specific stats on your website and social media, such as "This $10 shirt provides two hot meals."
Feature real stories of beneficiaries who have been helped by your nonprofit's services.
Spotlight donor stories to thank high-volume contributors and humanize the donation process.
Create video testimonials where thrift store volunteers explain their personal connections to the cause.
Feature a "Staff Picks" section where employees share their favorite items, along with a brief note explaining why they support the organization.
Ultimately, you know your audience best, so use your existing marketing data and best judgment to determine which messages will resonate with shoppers, inspire donors, boost volunteer recruitment, and engage other supporters. Nonprofits that communicate their impact effectively retain more shoppers who view their spending as a contribution to the community rather than just a retail expense.
4. Build Local Business Partnerships
According to Double the Donation, nonprofits that collaborate with local businesses often benefit from increased awareness of their cause and more funding for their missions. Depending on the type of partnership, it may even give you the opportunity to source new items for your inventory, further reducing costs.
Partnerships like these create a referral network, where each organization’s existing audience becomes more aware of the other organization. Here are a few examples of local business partnerships that might benefit your nonprofit thrift store:
Work with local real estate agents to provide "New Neighbor" donation packets for people moving into the area.
Connect with moving companies to offer their clients a list of accepted donation items during a transition.
Collaborate with local eco-friendly brands for joint social media campaigns centered on sustainability.
Work with local antique shops to cross-promote specialized items, referring customers back and forth based on specific collector interests.
Coordinate with local colleges to place donation bins in dormitories during move-out weeks.
Partner with professional organizers to provide their clients with a reliable outlet for decluttered items.
Choose your partnerships carefully. Ideally, you want to work with an organization that is tangentially related to your thrift store, so you’re getting access to an audience that’s likely already interested in your products. For example, if your thrift store only stocks clothing, you might partner with tailors and personal stylists.
Effective marketing for a nonprofit thrift store is rooted in community, visibility, and storytelling. Use your mission as the foundation for all your promotional material while maintaining professional retail standards to secure long-term success and community support.
This guest post was written by Kyle Payton.
With three years in the thrift industry during a pivotal shift to omnichannel selling, Kyle Payton helps stores better manage inventory and forecast product needs. As General Manager at ThriftCart, he focuses on equipping nonprofit thrift operations with point of sale technology that makes their day-to-day operations easier. Kyle’s passion lies in helping thrift store managers embrace digital solutions that support their unique mission and maximize their impact in the community.
“Supporting nonprofits is incredibly rewarding. I’m here to provide thrift store managers with the tools they need to thrive, so they can continue making a positive difference in their communities.”
Ready for more? Here are two ways Erin can help you make your mission irresistible to donors:
1. Connect with me or follow me on LinkedIn.
Let’s talk all things in the NP realm, donor strategy ideas, and whatever catches our fancy.
2. Work with me.
I guide NP teams to fund their mission with effective, frenzy-free donor engagement strategies.
✴️ Donors fund irresistible missions… is yours?
Schedule your 15-minute Change Chat here; let’s see if we should work together!